Hi. I looked at your website, here is what I offer and how I'm going to work:
1. First, I'll try to fix the error you're getting with your theme and Membership
plugin. I'll need to access to source code of the theme and plugin. In case it's not possible to easily fix the error, we will go with a different theme.
2. I'll setup Membership and Directory plugins as your described in your Outline file attachment. For Directory, we could use this plugin for example: [login to view URL]
It's free and frequently updated (last update was just 2 days ago).
3. For Resources, I'd recommend using Wordpress blog posts with custom layout for Reviews, Recipes, and Comparisons. I'll code them and also add related articles area.
4. I'll setup the Exchange Multi-item cart Add-on and hook it up with your PayPal, so you'll be able to sell stuff.
5. I'll create empty Services, Team, and other pages you listed so you can fill them up later with content.
6. I'll add ad widgets wherever you want. You'll be able to add/change/remove them in Wordpress Dashboard.
I estimate this will take about 4 days for me to complete (I bid 7 days just to be safe).
If you have any questions, please let me know!
I'm looking forward to hearing from you.
Thank you.
Sal